Training is an essential part of raising and living with a well-behaved and happy dog. However, there are times when training may not be the best solution—or when it needs to take a backseat to other priorities. Recognising when training isn’t suitable for your dog is key to supporting their overall well-being and ensuring they thrive both emotionally and physically.
Why Training Might Not Be the Answer
Training is often the first step people turn to when their dog exhibits unwanted behaviour.
While training can address many issues, it isn’t always the right solution in every situation. Some behaviours are rooted in underlying physical or emotional challenges that need to be resolved first.
For example:
A dog refusing to sit or lie down on cue may have joint pain or discomfort that makes the position uncomfortable.
A dog that appears unresponsive or “stubborn” may be feeling overwhelmed, fearful, or anxious in their environment.
A dog displaying reactive behaviours may not need "training” but rather help building confidence or recovering from a traumatic experience.
In these cases, focusing solely on training without addressing the root cause can lead to frustration and may even worsen the dog’s stress or discomfort.
Recognising When Training Isn’t Suitable
Knowing when to pause or adapt training involves being attentive to your dog’s physical and emotional state. Here are some signs to look out for:
Health Concerns: If your dog shows signs of pain, limping, stiffness, or reluctance to move, these could indicate underlying health issues that need veterinary attention.
Stress or Anxiety: Dogs that are panting excessively, pacing, trembling, or avoiding eye contact may be too stressed to engage in training effectively.
Fear Responses: If your dog is reacting to their environment with fear—such as cowering, growling, or attempting to flee—it’s a sign that they need reassurance and emotional support, not training.
Overexcitement or Fatigue: A dog that’s overly tired, overexcited, or mentally exhausted may struggle to focus, making training sessions unproductive.
What to Do Instead
When training isn’t suitable, it’s essential to take a step back and focus on your dog’s underlying needs.
Consult a Vet: If you suspect a medical issue is affecting your dog’s behaviour, a veterinary check-up is a priority. Conditions like arthritis, dental pain, or ear infections can all impact a dog’s willingness or ability to train.
Provide Emotional Support: Dogs experiencing fear or anxiety need time and patience to feel safe. Work on creating a calm and predictable environment where they can decompress. Gentle exposure to their triggers, paired with positive reinforcement, can help rebuild their confidence.
Meet Their Needs: Sometimes behavioural challenges arise from unmet needs, such as lack of exercise, mental stimulation, or opportunities to engage in natural behaviours like sniffing or chewing. Addressing these needs can often reduce unwanted behaviours without formal training.
Seek Specialist Help: If your dog’s behaviour is particularly challenging, a qualified canine behaviourist can help identify the root cause and develop a plan tailored to their needs. This approach focuses on understanding your dog’s emotions and motivations, rather than applying generic training methods.
Taking a Holistic Approach
Training is just one part of supporting your dog’s well-being. Recognising when it’s not suitable allows you to take a more holistic approach, addressing their physical health, emotional state, and environment. By prioritising their overall needs, you can create a foundation for effective training when the time is right.
Your dog’s behaviour is a form of communication. By listening to what they’re telling you and responding with empathy, you can build a stronger bond and help them thrive, no matter the situation.
Comments